Anchoring (a Cognitive Bias) Can Affect Outcome

July 31, 2020
4 minute read
Read

Anchoring is a cognitive bias about the human propensity to rely on the first piece of information when making decisions. Anchoring can stifle creativity, eliminate alternatives, and affect outcomes and decisions. This article provides a real-world example of calling out anchoring bias and taking action to provide a fair environment, and the difficult but necessary consequences that may follow.

Leading the Witness

Ron is a team member on a newly formed Scrum Team. Prior to being appointed Ron had worked alone building prototypes and solving technical problems for several stakeholders.

Once Ron became part of a team serving those same stakeholders he often struggled with sharing the knowledge and the notion of collaborative work. He frequently pointed out to his new team how he should be their Product Owner given his prior experience and knowledge.

Ron began adding items to the Product Backlog and prioritizing them to the top.  He felt these work items are necessary even though the stakeholders and customers had not asked for them.

Ron also brought up topics at the Sprint Retrospective he felt were important.  However, the team rarely voted to discuss his topics as they usually felt there were other more critical issues.  This frustrated Ron.  A day before a Sprint Retrospective he printed a list of topics and placed a copy on every team member’s desk along with issuing a directive to the team that these were the topics they would discuss at the next Sprint Retrospective.

Difficult Conversations

I do not like confrontation but as a Coach it is our job to help people understand the process and to reflect what we see and the impact they are having.  This means difficult conversations that require tact and empathy, and despite our best efforts sometimes it doesn’t go well.

I called Ron aside and tried to explain how he was influencing the team by declaring he was the expert and then overriding the Product Owner by indicating what work to do next.  I attempted to reflect on the impact of how he was influencing the team by re purposing a Scrum event and giving them an agenda for the Sprint Retrospective.  I gave him several specific examples of how this behaviour in the past had directly impacted the team’s decisions.  I then offered to help Ron get his thoughts across to the team by finding time in the next Sprint for him to explicitly discuss his work and improvement ideas.

Ron did not respond well to this feedback and summarily threw a temper tantrum, tossing his papers in the air, slamming the meeting room door open, storming through the team area, openly crying, and telling each and every one of the team members that I was unfair because I had upset him, was controlling him, and wouldn’t listen.  Needless to say the team was upset and blamed me for upsetting Ron.

Given the response I often ask myself what I could have done differently.   These are lessons for another day, but I strongly believe would not have been an effective coach if I had not spoken up about the anchoring and subverting of the Scrum Framework that I was witnessing.

The Impact

In this case, Ron was providing product backlog items and agenda topics, thereby anchoring the team in what they should work on, how they should do it, and even what topics they should discuss.  In essence he was forcibly attempting to bias the team and affect their outcome.

Although it was a difficult conversation I feel it was necessary to call out the bias I was witnessing and the impact it was having.

As humans we need to be aware of the many biases and prejudices we are subject to.  Unless we are impacted we are often often ignorant to their existence.  I cannot claim the moral high ground because I am just as guilty as anyone else of bias and prejudice, however by writing a series of articles I hope to educate myself and others to recognize patterns so we may all take appropriate action to mitigate or eliminate them.

 


 
If you find this useful, please consider contributing with our
Value for Value” model.

 


 

  • Certified ScrumMaster® (CSM) [Virtual Learning] badge

    Certified ScrumMaster® (CSM) [Virtual Learning]

    25 to 26 AUG 2020 - Starting Tuesday - Online - Mishkin Berteig

    C$1595.00 Register Now Only 2 Spots left!

    - Create Adaptive Product Teams in Any Business -

    This 2-day course provides the foundations to be an effective Scrum Master. Achieve Certified ScrumMaster® (CSM) designation by successfully completing this training and the online exam taken after the class (you'll receive the link directly from Scrum Alliance®).

    The Certified ScrumMaster® course is normally the recommended entry point to the practice of Scrum and is a prerequisite to more advanced certifications: A-CSM®, CSP-SM®.

    - 16 PDUs | 16 SEUs (REP with Scrum Alliance® and PMI)
    - Scrum Alliance® exam fee and 2-year membership included
    - In-depth simulation, engaging classroom discussion & no slides!

    Please register using a corporate email address, for corporate loyalty program discounts.

    __________________________________________________________________________

    IMPORTANT NOTE: This learning event requires:
    - 3 hours of Scrum preparatory work
    - review of Scrum foundational videos
    - completion of quizzes and SM-ready test


    All participants are expected to have completed the preparatory work before the start of the class. Failure to do so, will mean rescheduling and application of the $150 Rescheduling Fee.

    Location:

    Online

    Date:

    Tue 25-Aug-2020
    Wed 26-Aug-2020

    Time:

    09:00 AM to 04:30 PM (EST)

    Trainer:
    Mishkin Berteig

    Mishkin Berteig


    Chief Executive Officer
    About Trainer
  • Certified ScrumMaster® (CSM) [Virtual Learning] badge

    Certified ScrumMaster® (CSM) [Virtual Learning]

    09 to 10 SEP 2020 - Starting Wednesday - Online - Jerry Doucett & Mishkin Berteig

    C$1595.00 Register Now Only 13 Spots left!

    - Create Adaptive Product Teams in Any Business -

    This 2-day course provides the foundations to be an effective Scrum Master. Achieve Certified ScrumMaster® (CSM) designation by successfully completing this training and the online exam taken after the class (you'll receive the link directly from Scrum Alliance®).

    The Certified ScrumMaster® course is normally the recommended entry point to the practice of Scrum and is a prerequisite to more advanced certifications: A-CSM®, CSP-SM®.

    - 16 PDUs | 16 SEUs (REP with Scrum Alliance® and PMI)
    - Scrum Alliance® exam fee and 2-year membership included
    - In-depth simulation, engaging classroom discussion & no slides!

    Please register using a corporate email address, for corporate loyalty program discounts.

    __________________________________________________________________________

    IMPORTANT NOTE: This learning event requires:
    - 3 hours of Scrum preparatory work
    - review of Scrum foundational videos
    - completion of quizzes and SM-ready test


    All participants are expected to have completed the preparatory work before the start of the class. Failure to do so, will mean rescheduling and application of the $150 Rescheduling Fee.

    Location:

    Online

    Date:

    Wed 09-Sep-2020
    Thu 10-Sep-2020

    Time:

    09:00 AM to 04:30 PM (EST)

    Trainers:
    Jerry Doucett

    Jerry Doucett


    VP Training Services, Senior Consultant and Instructor
    About Trainer
    Mishkin Berteig

    Mishkin Berteig


    Chief Executive Officer
    About Trainer
  • Certified ScrumMaster® (CSM) [Virtual Learning] badge

    Certified ScrumMaster® (CSM) [Virtual Learning]

    22 to 23 SEP 2020 - Starting Tuesday - Online - Jerry Doucett & Mishkin Berteig

    Early-bird Discount! C$1595.00 C$1355.75 Until 31-Aug-2020 Register Now

    - Create Adaptive Product Teams in Any Business -

    This 2-day course provides the foundations to be an effective Scrum Master. Achieve Certified ScrumMaster® (CSM) designation by successfully completing this training and the online exam taken after the class (you'll receive the link directly from Scrum Alliance®).

    The Certified ScrumMaster® course is normally the recommended entry point to the practice of Scrum and is a prerequisite to more advanced certifications: A-CSM®, CSP-SM®.

    - 16 PDUs | 16 SEUs (REP with Scrum Alliance® and PMI)
    - Scrum Alliance® exam fee and 2-year membership included
    - In-depth simulation, engaging classroom discussion & no slides!

    Please register using a corporate email address, for corporate loyalty program discounts.

    __________________________________________________________________________

    IMPORTANT NOTE: This learning event requires:
    - 3 hours of Scrum preparatory work
    - review of Scrum foundational videos
    - completion of quizzes and SM-ready test


    All participants are expected to have completed the preparatory work before the start of the class. Failure to do so, will mean rescheduling and application of the $150 Rescheduling Fee.

    Location:

    Online

    Date:

    Tue 22-Sep-2020
    Wed 23-Sep-2020

    Time:

    09:00 AM to 04:30 PM (EST)

    Trainers:
    Jerry Doucett

    Jerry Doucett


    VP Training Services, Senior Consultant and Instructor
    About Trainer
    Mishkin Berteig

    Mishkin Berteig


    Chief Executive Officer
    About Trainer
  • Certified ScrumMaster® (CSM) [Virtual Learning] badge

    Certified ScrumMaster® (CSM) [Virtual Learning]

    06 to 07 OCT 2020 - Starting Tuesday - Online - Mishkin Berteig

    Early-bird Discount! C$1595.00 C$1355.75 Until 07-Sep-2020 Register Now

    - Create Adaptive Product Teams in Any Business -

    This 2-day course provides the foundations to be an effective Scrum Master. Achieve Certified ScrumMaster® (CSM) designation by successfully completing this training and the online exam taken after the class (you'll receive the link directly from Scrum Alliance®).

    The Certified ScrumMaster® course is normally the recommended entry point to the practice of Scrum and is a prerequisite to more advanced certifications: A-CSM®, CSP-SM®.

    - 16 PDUs | 16 SEUs (REP with Scrum Alliance® and PMI)
    - Scrum Alliance® exam fee and 2-year membership included
    - In-depth simulation, engaging classroom discussion & no slides!

    Please register using a corporate email address, for corporate loyalty program discounts.

    __________________________________________________________________________

    IMPORTANT NOTE: This learning event requires:
    - 3 hours of Scrum preparatory work
    - review of Scrum foundational videos
    - completion of quizzes and SM-ready test


    All participants are expected to have completed the preparatory work before the start of the class. Failure to do so, will mean rescheduling and application of the $150 Rescheduling Fee.

    Location:

    Online

    Date:

    Tue 06-Oct-2020
    Wed 07-Oct-2020

    Time:

    09:00 AM to 04:30 PM (EST)

    Trainer:
    Mishkin Berteig

    Mishkin Berteig


    Chief Executive Officer
    About Trainer
  • Certified ScrumMaster® (CSM) [Virtual Learning] badge

    Certified ScrumMaster® (CSM) [Virtual Learning]

    20 to 21 OCT 2020 - Starting Tuesday - Online - Mishkin Berteig

    Early-bird Discount! C$1595.00 C$1355.75 Until 21-Sep-2020 Register Now

    - Create Adaptive Product Teams in Any Business -

    This 2-day course provides the foundations to be an effective Scrum Master. Achieve Certified ScrumMaster® (CSM) designation by successfully completing this training and the online exam taken after the class (you'll receive the link directly from Scrum Alliance®).

    The Certified ScrumMaster® course is normally the recommended entry point to the practice of Scrum and is a prerequisite to more advanced certifications: A-CSM®, CSP-SM®.

    - 16 PDUs | 16 SEUs (REP with Scrum Alliance® and PMI)
    - Scrum Alliance® exam fee and 2-year membership included
    - In-depth simulation, engaging classroom discussion & no slides!

    Please register using a corporate email address, for corporate loyalty program discounts.

    __________________________________________________________________________

    IMPORTANT NOTE: This learning event requires:
    - 3 hours of Scrum preparatory work
    - review of Scrum foundational videos
    - completion of quizzes and SM-ready test


    All participants are expected to have completed the preparatory work before the start of the class. Failure to do so, will mean rescheduling and application of the $150 Rescheduling Fee.

    Location:

    Online

    Date:

    Tue 20-Oct-2020
    Wed 21-Oct-2020

    Time:

    09:00 AM to 04:30 PM (EST)

    Trainer:
    Mishkin Berteig

    Mishkin Berteig


    Chief Executive Officer
    About Trainer
  • Certified ScrumMaster® (CSM) [Virtual Learning] badge

    Certified ScrumMaster® (CSM) [Virtual Learning]

    03 to 04 NOV 2020 - Starting Tuesday - Online - Mishkin Berteig

    Early-bird Discount! C$1595.00 C$1355.75 Until 05-Oct-2020 Register Now

    - Create Adaptive Product Teams in Any Business -

    This 2-day course provides the foundations to be an effective Scrum Master. Achieve Certified ScrumMaster® (CSM) designation by successfully completing this training and the online exam taken after the class (you'll receive the link directly from Scrum Alliance®).

    The Certified ScrumMaster® course is normally the recommended entry point to the practice of Scrum and is a prerequisite to more advanced certifications: A-CSM®, CSP-SM®.

    - 16 PDUs | 16 SEUs (REP with Scrum Alliance® and PMI)
    - Scrum Alliance® exam fee and 2-year membership included
    - In-depth simulation, engaging classroom discussion & no slides!

    Please register using a corporate email address, for corporate loyalty program discounts.

    __________________________________________________________________________

    IMPORTANT NOTE: This learning event requires:
    - 3 hours of Scrum preparatory work
    - review of Scrum foundational videos
    - completion of quizzes and SM-ready test


    All participants are expected to have completed the preparatory work before the start of the class. Failure to do so, will mean rescheduling and application of the $150 Rescheduling Fee.

    Location:

    Online

    Date:

    Tue 03-Nov-2020
    Wed 04-Nov-2020

    Time:

    09:00 AM to 04:30 PM (EST)

    Trainer:
    Mishkin Berteig

    Mishkin Berteig


    Chief Executive Officer
    About Trainer
  • Kanban System Design® (KMP I) [Virtual Learning] badge

    Kanban System Design® (KMP I) [Virtual Learning]

    30 SEP to 01 OCT 2020 - Starting Wednesday - Online - Jerry Doucett

    Early-bird Discount! C$1795.00 C$1525.75 Until 01-Sep-2020 Register Now Only 15 Spots left!

    - Improve Knowledge Work Productivity -

    This 2-day workshop - also known as 'Kanban for Real Agility®' - gives you the fundamentals of the Kanban Method® for leaders starting their organization on the gentle path to Real Agility™. This learning event is ideal for you if you are responsible for the delivery of a service. Learn the concepts of flow, pull, classes of service and learn to deal with interruptions and multi-tasking. Learn the Systems Thinking Approach To Implementing Kanban (STATIK).

    This course, known as Kanban Management Professional 1 (KMP I), is the first of two courses towards the Kanban Management Professional (KMP) credential. KMP I is the prerequisite to KMP II. By completing both KMP I and KMP II, participants can achieve the KMP credential with the Lean Kanban University®.

    - Participate in the Get Kanban simulation for immersive learning
    - Design your service's Kanban board with guidance from our trainer
    - Start your Kanban adoption
    - 14 PDUs | 14 SEUs
    - Profile listing on the LKU alumni page
    - Registered Education Provider with LKU
    - Taught by Accredited Kanban Trainers only

    EXCLUSIVE: Free "Kanban for Managers" e-book written by BERTEIG consultants!

    Download your copy of the pre-reading book by David J. Anderson and Andy Carmichael:
    Essential Kanban Condensed: https://resources.kanban.university/guide/

    Please register using a corporate email address, for corporate loyalty program discounts.

    --
    Both KMP I and KMP II must be completed to achieve the designation.

    KMP I

    Location:

    Online

    Date:

    Wed 30-Sep-2020
    Thu 01-Oct-2020

    Time:

    09:00 AM to 05:00 PM (EST)

    Trainer:
    Jerry Doucett

    Jerry Doucett


    VP Training Services, Senior Consultant and Instructor
    About Trainer
  • Kanban System Design® (KMPI) [Virtual Learning] badge

    Kanban System Design® (KMPI) [Virtual Learning]

    19 to 20 NOV 2020 - Starting Thursday - Online - Jerry Doucett

    Early-bird Discount! C$1795.00 C$1525.75 Until 18-Oct-2020 Register Now

    - Improve Knowledge Work Productivity -

    This 2-day workshop - also known as 'Kanban for Real Agility®' - gives you the fundamentals of the Kanban Method® for leaders starting their organization on the gentle path to Real Agility™. This learning event is ideal for you if you are responsible for the delivery of a service. Learn the concepts of flow, pull, classes of service and learn to deal with interruptions and multi-tasking. Learn the Systems Thinking Approach To Implementing Kanban (STATIK).

    This course, known as Kanban Management Professional 1 (KMP I), is the first of two courses towards the Kanban Management Professional (KMP) credential. KMP I is the prerequisite to KMP II. By completing both KMP I and KMP II, participants can achieve the KMP credential with the Lean Kanban University®.

    - Participate in the Get Kanban simulation for immersive learning
    - Design your service's Kanban board with guidance from our trainer
    - Start your Kanban adoption
    - 14 PDUs | 14 SEUs
    - Profile listing on the LKU alumni page
    - Registered Education Provider with LKU
    - Taught by Accredited Kanban Trainers only

    EXCLUSIVE: Free "Kanban for Managers" e-book written by BERTEIG consultants!

    Download your copy of the pre-reading book by David J. Anderson and Andy Carmichael:
    Essential Kanban Condensed: https://resources.kanban.university/guide/

    Please register using a corporate email address, for corporate loyalty program discounts.

    Location:

    Online

    Date:

    Thu 19-Nov-2020
    Fri 20-Nov-2020

    Time:

    09:00 AM to 05:00 PM (EST)

    Trainer:
    Jerry Doucett

    Jerry Doucett


    VP Training Services, Senior Consultant and Instructor
    About Trainer

Berteig Consulting

Empower Your Entire Organization with BERTEIG Consulting in Agile, Scrum, Kanban, SAFe and LEAN.

Aimia
Bruce Power
Capital One
CBC
Comcast
Equitable Life of Canada
FreshBooks
Suncor