OpenAgile is not (just) Empirical

May 29, 2020
5 minute read
Read
I admit it: OpenAgile is my baby. As one of the founders of the method, I sometimes come across people who want me to justify its existence as a separate method. This article is one part of that discussion that focuses on a fundamental difference between OpenAgile and its progenitor, Scrum.

A few weeks ago, David Parker and I had a conversation about some of the differences between Scrum and OpenAgile.  We hit upon one really interesting thing: Scrum strongly emphasizes that it is a purely empirical approach to doing work… and OpenAgile does not make that claim.  In fact, OpenAgile, while it includes empiricism, is definitely not an empirical process framework.

Ken Schwaber has long been adamant about empiricism with his phrase “Inspect and Adapt” which is the core of Scrum.  All the artifacts, meetings and roles of Scrum are meant to be supportive of the inspect and adapt approach in a product development environment.  A Scrum self-organizing team inspects and adapts on the product it is building.  It inspects and adapts on the obstacles that arise as it does its work.  It inspects and adapts on all the organizational processes, technical tools, team dynamics,… everything!  This is Good.

But Scrum, in its pure empiricism, also lacks something.

OpenAgile CircleOpenAgile has components of Scrum’s empiricism.  Certainly, OpenAgile owes a great deal to Scrum.  The concept of “Systematic Learning”, one of the foundations of OpenAgile, is similar to Scrum’s empirical framework.  The process structure of OpenAgile is also similar to that of Scrum with short cycles of work delivering value on a regular basis.  The main difference comes from a simple concept: Guidance.

In OpenAgile, guidance is a critical component of systematic learning.  Guidance allows someone outside the team to intervene.  This might be a manager, a stakeholder, a family member… anyone who sees things from an “outside” perspective.  It might also be someone within the team pulling in guidance: asking for advice, doing a web search, reading a book, or even meditating in the hope of inspiration.

In Scrum, there are some very strong boundaries around outsiders providing guidance.  No changes mid-sprint.  All requests for work go through the Team’s Product Owner.  The ScrumMaster “protects” the team from outside interruptions.  “Chickens” cannot participate in the Daily Scrum.  The team self-organizes with individuals volunteering for specific tasks.  Team members discard all organizational titles when working within a Scrum team.  All of these boundaries support a pure empirical approach to working.  They also provide a form of safety for the team.  This safety is deemed necessary with the implication that stuff from outside the team is dangerous.

In OpenAgile, guidance comes to the team through the conduit of love.  Yes… love.

The team develops a love for its work.  This love then opens the team members to guidance.  Think of the opposite: if I hate my work, I’m not likely to be interested in taking any advice about how to do it better.  If I love my work, I will always be seeking ways to improve it.

Of course, love is not binary.  It’s not on or off.  In that continuum, the more an OpenAgile team loves its work, the more receptive it will be to guidance.  The more receptive to guidance, the more sources of guidance will be “safe”.  And the less reliance on pure empiricism will be necessary.

Let’s be frank: pure empiricism, in its most extreme form, means that Scrum teams would re-invent things that may have already been invented many times before.  In the Scrum community, the most obvious example of this is the Agile engineering practices that come from Extreme Programming.  Scrum teams seem remarkably resistant to adopting these practices at the outset… despite the fact that eventually most Scrum teams working in software succeed or fail based on their eventual adoption of these practices.  Scrum teams are often left without the guidance that XP practices can help them.  Instead Scrum teams seem expected to re-discover XP practices on their own.

For what it’s worth, I don’t think that Scrum is fatally flawed.  In fact, I think that in some environments, where teams truly are unsafe, where people tend to hate their work, where dysfunctional bureaucracy is deeply embedded in the organization’s culture… in these environments Scrum is actually the right place to start.  Scrum is great for product development in high-crisis situations: save your product with Scrum!

OpenAgile, by accepting guidance into its framework, allows teams to progress rapidly when they can leverage other people’s learning.  Scrum does not dis-allow this, but it sets up an environment where the team culture tends towards the “Not Invented Here” syndrome.  OpenAgile puts teams on the other path: the path of allowing for greater and greater learning from others.

[This article was originally published on Agile Advice on 26-Sept-2011]


 
If you find this useful, please consider contributing with our
Value for Value” model.

 


 

  • Certified ScrumMaster® (CSM) [Virtual Learning] badge

    Certified ScrumMaster® (CSM) [Virtual Learning]

    25 to 26 AUG 2020 - Starting Tuesday - Online - Mishkin Berteig

    C$1595.00 Register Now Only 2 Spots left!

    - Create Adaptive Product Teams in Any Business -

    This 2-day course provides the foundations to be an effective Scrum Master. Achieve Certified ScrumMaster® (CSM) designation by successfully completing this training and the online exam taken after the class (you'll receive the link directly from Scrum Alliance®).

    The Certified ScrumMaster® course is normally the recommended entry point to the practice of Scrum and is a prerequisite to more advanced certifications: A-CSM®, CSP-SM®.

    - 16 PDUs | 16 SEUs (REP with Scrum Alliance® and PMI)
    - Scrum Alliance® exam fee and 2-year membership included
    - In-depth simulation, engaging classroom discussion & no slides!

    Please register using a corporate email address, for corporate loyalty program discounts.

    __________________________________________________________________________

    IMPORTANT NOTE: This learning event requires:
    - 3 hours of Scrum preparatory work
    - review of Scrum foundational videos
    - completion of quizzes and SM-ready test


    All participants are expected to have completed the preparatory work before the start of the class. Failure to do so, will mean rescheduling and application of the $150 Rescheduling Fee.

    Location:

    Online

    Date:

    Tue 25-Aug-2020
    Wed 26-Aug-2020

    Time:

    09:00 AM to 04:30 PM (EST)

    Trainer:
    Mishkin Berteig

    Mishkin Berteig


    Chief Executive Officer
    About Trainer
  • Certified ScrumMaster® (CSM) [Virtual Learning] badge

    Certified ScrumMaster® (CSM) [Virtual Learning]

    09 to 10 SEP 2020 - Starting Wednesday - Online - Jerry Doucett & Mishkin Berteig

    C$1595.00 Register Now Only 13 Spots left!

    - Create Adaptive Product Teams in Any Business -

    This 2-day course provides the foundations to be an effective Scrum Master. Achieve Certified ScrumMaster® (CSM) designation by successfully completing this training and the online exam taken after the class (you'll receive the link directly from Scrum Alliance®).

    The Certified ScrumMaster® course is normally the recommended entry point to the practice of Scrum and is a prerequisite to more advanced certifications: A-CSM®, CSP-SM®.

    - 16 PDUs | 16 SEUs (REP with Scrum Alliance® and PMI)
    - Scrum Alliance® exam fee and 2-year membership included
    - In-depth simulation, engaging classroom discussion & no slides!

    Please register using a corporate email address, for corporate loyalty program discounts.

    __________________________________________________________________________

    IMPORTANT NOTE: This learning event requires:
    - 3 hours of Scrum preparatory work
    - review of Scrum foundational videos
    - completion of quizzes and SM-ready test


    All participants are expected to have completed the preparatory work before the start of the class. Failure to do so, will mean rescheduling and application of the $150 Rescheduling Fee.

    Location:

    Online

    Date:

    Wed 09-Sep-2020
    Thu 10-Sep-2020

    Time:

    09:00 AM to 04:30 PM (EST)

    Trainers:
    Jerry Doucett

    Jerry Doucett


    VP Training Services, Senior Consultant and Instructor
    About Trainer
    Mishkin Berteig

    Mishkin Berteig


    Chief Executive Officer
    About Trainer
  • Certified ScrumMaster® (CSM) [Virtual Learning] badge

    Certified ScrumMaster® (CSM) [Virtual Learning]

    22 to 23 SEP 2020 - Starting Tuesday - Online - Jerry Doucett & Mishkin Berteig

    Early-bird Discount! C$1595.00 C$1355.75 Until 31-Aug-2020 Register Now

    - Create Adaptive Product Teams in Any Business -

    This 2-day course provides the foundations to be an effective Scrum Master. Achieve Certified ScrumMaster® (CSM) designation by successfully completing this training and the online exam taken after the class (you'll receive the link directly from Scrum Alliance®).

    The Certified ScrumMaster® course is normally the recommended entry point to the practice of Scrum and is a prerequisite to more advanced certifications: A-CSM®, CSP-SM®.

    - 16 PDUs | 16 SEUs (REP with Scrum Alliance® and PMI)
    - Scrum Alliance® exam fee and 2-year membership included
    - In-depth simulation, engaging classroom discussion & no slides!

    Please register using a corporate email address, for corporate loyalty program discounts.

    __________________________________________________________________________

    IMPORTANT NOTE: This learning event requires:
    - 3 hours of Scrum preparatory work
    - review of Scrum foundational videos
    - completion of quizzes and SM-ready test


    All participants are expected to have completed the preparatory work before the start of the class. Failure to do so, will mean rescheduling and application of the $150 Rescheduling Fee.

    Location:

    Online

    Date:

    Tue 22-Sep-2020
    Wed 23-Sep-2020

    Time:

    09:00 AM to 04:30 PM (EST)

    Trainers:
    Jerry Doucett

    Jerry Doucett


    VP Training Services, Senior Consultant and Instructor
    About Trainer
    Mishkin Berteig

    Mishkin Berteig


    Chief Executive Officer
    About Trainer
  • Certified ScrumMaster® (CSM) [Virtual Learning] badge

    Certified ScrumMaster® (CSM) [Virtual Learning]

    06 to 07 OCT 2020 - Starting Tuesday - Online - Mishkin Berteig

    Early-bird Discount! C$1595.00 C$1355.75 Until 07-Sep-2020 Register Now

    - Create Adaptive Product Teams in Any Business -

    This 2-day course provides the foundations to be an effective Scrum Master. Achieve Certified ScrumMaster® (CSM) designation by successfully completing this training and the online exam taken after the class (you'll receive the link directly from Scrum Alliance®).

    The Certified ScrumMaster® course is normally the recommended entry point to the practice of Scrum and is a prerequisite to more advanced certifications: A-CSM®, CSP-SM®.

    - 16 PDUs | 16 SEUs (REP with Scrum Alliance® and PMI)
    - Scrum Alliance® exam fee and 2-year membership included
    - In-depth simulation, engaging classroom discussion & no slides!

    Please register using a corporate email address, for corporate loyalty program discounts.

    __________________________________________________________________________

    IMPORTANT NOTE: This learning event requires:
    - 3 hours of Scrum preparatory work
    - review of Scrum foundational videos
    - completion of quizzes and SM-ready test


    All participants are expected to have completed the preparatory work before the start of the class. Failure to do so, will mean rescheduling and application of the $150 Rescheduling Fee.

    Location:

    Online

    Date:

    Tue 06-Oct-2020
    Wed 07-Oct-2020

    Time:

    09:00 AM to 04:30 PM (EST)

    Trainer:
    Mishkin Berteig

    Mishkin Berteig


    Chief Executive Officer
    About Trainer
  • Certified ScrumMaster® (CSM) [Virtual Learning] badge

    Certified ScrumMaster® (CSM) [Virtual Learning]

    20 to 21 OCT 2020 - Starting Tuesday - Online - Mishkin Berteig

    Early-bird Discount! C$1595.00 C$1355.75 Until 21-Sep-2020 Register Now

    - Create Adaptive Product Teams in Any Business -

    This 2-day course provides the foundations to be an effective Scrum Master. Achieve Certified ScrumMaster® (CSM) designation by successfully completing this training and the online exam taken after the class (you'll receive the link directly from Scrum Alliance®).

    The Certified ScrumMaster® course is normally the recommended entry point to the practice of Scrum and is a prerequisite to more advanced certifications: A-CSM®, CSP-SM®.

    - 16 PDUs | 16 SEUs (REP with Scrum Alliance® and PMI)
    - Scrum Alliance® exam fee and 2-year membership included
    - In-depth simulation, engaging classroom discussion & no slides!

    Please register using a corporate email address, for corporate loyalty program discounts.

    __________________________________________________________________________

    IMPORTANT NOTE: This learning event requires:
    - 3 hours of Scrum preparatory work
    - review of Scrum foundational videos
    - completion of quizzes and SM-ready test


    All participants are expected to have completed the preparatory work before the start of the class. Failure to do so, will mean rescheduling and application of the $150 Rescheduling Fee.

    Location:

    Online

    Date:

    Tue 20-Oct-2020
    Wed 21-Oct-2020

    Time:

    09:00 AM to 04:30 PM (EST)

    Trainer:
    Mishkin Berteig

    Mishkin Berteig


    Chief Executive Officer
    About Trainer
  • Certified ScrumMaster® (CSM) [Virtual Learning] badge

    Certified ScrumMaster® (CSM) [Virtual Learning]

    03 to 04 NOV 2020 - Starting Tuesday - Online - Mishkin Berteig

    Early-bird Discount! C$1595.00 C$1355.75 Until 05-Oct-2020 Register Now

    - Create Adaptive Product Teams in Any Business -

    This 2-day course provides the foundations to be an effective Scrum Master. Achieve Certified ScrumMaster® (CSM) designation by successfully completing this training and the online exam taken after the class (you'll receive the link directly from Scrum Alliance®).

    The Certified ScrumMaster® course is normally the recommended entry point to the practice of Scrum and is a prerequisite to more advanced certifications: A-CSM®, CSP-SM®.

    - 16 PDUs | 16 SEUs (REP with Scrum Alliance® and PMI)
    - Scrum Alliance® exam fee and 2-year membership included
    - In-depth simulation, engaging classroom discussion & no slides!

    Please register using a corporate email address, for corporate loyalty program discounts.

    __________________________________________________________________________

    IMPORTANT NOTE: This learning event requires:
    - 3 hours of Scrum preparatory work
    - review of Scrum foundational videos
    - completion of quizzes and SM-ready test


    All participants are expected to have completed the preparatory work before the start of the class. Failure to do so, will mean rescheduling and application of the $150 Rescheduling Fee.

    Location:

    Online

    Date:

    Tue 03-Nov-2020
    Wed 04-Nov-2020

    Time:

    09:00 AM to 04:30 PM (EST)

    Trainer:
    Mishkin Berteig

    Mishkin Berteig


    Chief Executive Officer
    About Trainer
  • Certified Scrum Product Owner® (CSPO) [Virtual Learning] badge

    Certified Scrum Product Owner® (CSPO) [Virtual Learning]

    18 to 19 AUG 2020 - Starting Tuesday - Online - Mishkin Berteig

    C$1795.00 Register Now Only 4 Spots left!

    - Manage your backlog to achieve maximum ROI -

    This 2-day course provides the foundations to be an effective Product Owner. Successful completion of this course leads to becoming a Certified Scrum Product Owner® (CSPO) with Scrum Alliance®.

    The Certified Scrum Product Owner® (CSPO) course is ideally suited to those working with the 'business' and whose priorities include satisfying the needs of the customer.

    It is valuable to have already taken the Certified ScrumMaster® (CSM) prior to taking this course. This class leads to the more advanced certifications: A-CSPO® and CSP-PO®.

    - 16 PDUs | 16 SEUs (REP with Scrum Alliance® & PMI®)
    - 2-year membership with Scrum Alliance® included
    - Access 2 free e-books: "The Scrum Product Owner" and "Agile Advice"
    - No slides! In-depth simulation, classroom discussion

    Please register using a corporate email address, for corporate loyalty program discounts.



    IMPORTANT NOTE: This learning event requires:
    - 2 hours of Scrum preparatory work
    - review of Scrum foundational videos
    - completion of quizzes and PO-ready test


    All participants are expected to have completed the preparatory work before the start of the class. Failure to do so, will mean rescheduling and application of the $150 Rescheduling Fee.

    Location:

    Online

    Date:

    Tue 18-Aug-2020
    Wed 19-Aug-2020

    Time:

    09:00 AM to 04:30 PM (EST)

    Trainer:
    Mishkin Berteig

    Mishkin Berteig


    Chief Executive Officer
    About Trainer
  • Certified Scrum Product Owner® (CSPO) [Virtual Learning] badge

    Certified Scrum Product Owner® (CSPO) [Virtual Learning]

    29 to 30 SEP 2020 - Starting Tuesday - Online - David Vicentin & Mishkin Berteig

    Early-bird Discount! C$1795.00 C$1525.75 Until 30-Aug-2020 Register Now

    - Manage your backlog to achieve maximum ROI -

    This 2-day course provides the foundations to be an effective Product Owner. Successful completion of this course leads to becoming a Certified Scrum Product Owner® (CSPO) with Scrum Alliance®.

    The Certified Scrum Product Owner® (CSPO) course is ideally suited to those working with the 'business' and whose priorities include satisfying the needs of the customer.

    It is valuable to have already taken the Certified ScrumMaster® (CSM) prior to taking this course. This class leads to the more advanced certifications: A-CSPO® and CSP-PO®.

    - 16 PDUs | 16 SEUs (REP with Scrum Alliance® & PMI®)
    - 2-year membership with Scrum Alliance® included
    - Access 2 free e-books: "The Scrum Product Owner" and "Agile Advice"
    - No slides! In-depth simulation, classroom discussion

    Please register using a corporate email address, for corporate loyalty program discounts.



    IMPORTANT NOTE: This learning event requires:
    - 2 hours of Scrum preparatory work
    - review of Scrum foundational videos
    - completion of quizzes and PO-ready test


    All participants are expected to have completed the preparatory work before the start of the class. Failure to do so, will mean rescheduling and application of the $150 Rescheduling Fee.

    Location:

    Online

    Date:

    Tue 29-Sep-2020
    Wed 30-Sep-2020

    Time:

    09:00 AM to 04:30 PM (EST)

    Trainers:
    David Vicentin

    David Vicentin


    Senior Agile/Lean Consultant
    About Trainer
    Mishkin Berteig

    Mishkin Berteig


    Chief Executive Officer
    About Trainer
  • Certified Scrum Product Owner® (CSPO) [Virtual Learning] badge

    Certified Scrum Product Owner® (CSPO) [Virtual Learning]

    27 to 28 OCT 2020 - Starting Tuesday - Online - Mishkin Berteig

    Early-bird Discount! C$1795.00 C$1525.75 Until 28-Sep-2020 Register Now

    - Manage your backlog to achieve maximum ROI -

    This 2-day course provides the foundations to be an effective Product Owner. Successful completion of this course leads to becoming a Certified Scrum Product Owner® (CSPO) with Scrum Alliance®.

    The Certified Scrum Product Owner® (CSPO) course is ideally suited to those working with the 'business' and whose priorities include satisfying the needs of the customer.

    It is valuable to have already taken the Certified ScrumMaster® (CSM) prior to taking this course. This class leads to the more advanced certifications: A-CSPO® and CSP-PO®.

    - 16 PDUs | 16 SEUs (REP with Scrum Alliance® & PMI®)
    - 2-year membership with Scrum Alliance® included
    - Access 2 free e-books: "The Scrum Product Owner" and "Agile Advice"
    - No slides! In-depth simulation, classroom discussion

    Please register using a corporate email address, for corporate loyalty program discounts.



    IMPORTANT NOTE: This learning event requires:
    - 2 hours of Scrum preparatory work
    - review of Scrum foundational videos
    - completion of quizzes and PO-ready test


    All participants are expected to have completed the preparatory work before the start of the class. Failure to do so, will mean rescheduling and application of the $150 Rescheduling Fee.

    Location:

    Online

    Date:

    Tue 27-Oct-2020
    Wed 28-Oct-2020

    Time:

    09:00 AM to 04:30 PM (EST)

    Trainer:
    Mishkin Berteig

    Mishkin Berteig


    Chief Executive Officer
    About Trainer
  • Certified Scrum Product Owner® (CSPO) [Virtual Learning] badge

    Certified Scrum Product Owner® (CSPO) [Virtual Learning]

    24 to 25 NOV 2020 - Starting Tuesday - Online - Mishkin Berteig

    Early-bird Discount! C$1795.00 C$1525.75 Until 26-Oct-2020 Register Now

    - Manage your backlog to achieve maximum ROI -

    This 2-day course provides the foundations to be an effective Product Owner. Successful completion of this course leads to becoming a Certified Scrum Product Owner® (CSPO) with Scrum Alliance®.

    The Certified Scrum Product Owner® (CSPO) course is ideally suited to those working with the 'business' and whose priorities include satisfying the needs of the customer.

    It is valuable to have already taken the Certified ScrumMaster® (CSM) prior to taking this course. This class leads to the more advanced certifications: A-CSPO® and CSP-PO®.

    - 16 PDUs | 16 SEUs (REP with Scrum Alliance® & PMI®)
    - 2-year membership with Scrum Alliance® included
    - Access 2 free e-books: "The Scrum Product Owner" and "Agile Advice"
    - No slides! In-depth simulation, classroom discussion

    Please register using a corporate email address, for corporate loyalty program discounts.



    IMPORTANT NOTE: This learning event requires:
    - 2 hours of Scrum preparatory work
    - review of Scrum foundational videos
    - completion of quizzes and PO-ready test


    All participants are expected to have completed the preparatory work before the start of the class. Failure to do so, will mean rescheduling and application of the $150 Rescheduling Fee.

    Location:

    Online

    Date:

    Tue 24-Nov-2020
    Wed 25-Nov-2020

    Time:

    09:00 AM to 04:30 PM (EST)

    Trainer:
    Mishkin Berteig

    Mishkin Berteig


    Chief Executive Officer
    About Trainer
  • Certified Scrum Product Owner® (CSPO) [Virtual Learning] badge

    Certified Scrum Product Owner® (CSPO) [Virtual Learning]

    15 to 16 DEC 2020 - Starting Tuesday - Online - Mishkin Berteig

    Early-bird Discount! C$1795.00 C$1525.75 Until 16-Nov-2020 Register Now

    - Manage your backlog to achieve maximum ROI -

    This 2-day course provides the foundations to be an effective Product Owner. Successful completion of this course leads to becoming a Certified Scrum Product Owner® (CSPO) with Scrum Alliance®.

    The Certified Scrum Product Owner® (CSPO) course is ideally suited to those working with the 'business' and whose priorities include satisfying the needs of the customer.

    It is valuable to have already taken the Certified ScrumMaster® (CSM) prior to taking this course. This class leads to the more advanced certifications: A-CSPO® and CSP-PO®.

    - 16 PDUs | 16 SEUs (REP with Scrum Alliance® & PMI®)
    - 2-year membership with Scrum Alliance® included
    - Access 2 free e-books: "The Scrum Product Owner" and "Agile Advice"
    - No slides! In-depth simulation, classroom discussion

    Please register using a corporate email address, for corporate loyalty program discounts.



    IMPORTANT NOTE: This learning event requires:
    - 2 hours of Scrum preparatory work
    - review of Scrum foundational videos
    - completion of quizzes and PO-ready test


    All participants are expected to have completed the preparatory work before the start of the class. Failure to do so, will mean rescheduling and application of the $150 Rescheduling Fee.

    Location:

    Online

    Date:

    Tue 15-Dec-2020
    Wed 16-Dec-2020

    Time:

    09:00 AM to 04:30 PM (EST)

    Trainer:
    Mishkin Berteig

    Mishkin Berteig


    Chief Executive Officer
    About Trainer

Berteig Consulting

Empower Your Entire Organization with BERTEIG Consulting in Agile, Scrum, Kanban, SAFe and LEAN.

Aimia
Bruce Power
Capital One
CBC
Comcast
Equitable Life of Canada
FreshBooks
Suncor